Comments (0) | Link to this story | Send to a friend | Print Story

Lawmakers on Thursday morning turned away a measure requiring all school districts to adopt bullying policies.

Members of Senate Education deferred SB 104 to the 41st Legislative Day on a 4-3 vote, effectively killing the legislation for a third year in a row. Legislators who voted against the bill said local schools should be given the full authority to address bullying.

“We’re not hard-hearted,” said Sen. Elizabeth Kraus, R-Rapid City, before voting to kill the measure. “We just truly believe it’s a local control issue.”

Sen. Stan Adelstein, R- Rapid City, told the panel that South Dakota has the highest percentage in the nation of students who commit suicide – something he said the bullying legislation would work to counter. He urged lawmakers to endorse the measure, saying it was a “matter of helping children to stay alive.”

ASBSD supported the bill based on a resolution adopted in November by the ASBSD Delegate Assembly. Representatives from local school boards told ASBSD staff to support legislation that requires local school boards to adopt written bullying prevention policies, provided the legislation gives local school boards flexibility

“Everything in the bill as written adheres to the position our school board members have taken,” said ASBSD Director of Legal Services Bill Engberg.

Representatives from other education organizations lined up against the bill, including lobbyists for school administrators, small schools, mid-sized schools, large schools and Rapid City and Sioux Falls. All opposed the measure on the grounds that it went too far into local decision-making.

Comments (1) | Link to this story | Send to a friend | Print Story

A third attempt to revive a bill that would require all schools to adopt bullying policies has stalled on the House floor.

Lawmakers decided Tuesday not to allow further debate on HB 1279, ending a procedural maneuver called a “smoke-out” that allows lawmakers to circumvent the committee process to pass legislation.

In this case, lawmakers voted 36-34 to uphold the House Education Committee's recommendation that the bill “Do Not Pass.” By sticking with the committee recommendation, the issue was not granted a debate on the House floor.

Following the failure of the smoke-out, ASBSD lobbyists learned that the bill's sponsor, Rep. Dan Lederman, R-Dakota Dunes, may try to revive the issue in the Senate Education Committee.

Comments (0) | Link to this story | Send to a friend | Print Story

Members of House Education rejected HB 1279 on an 8-7 vote, capping a lengthy discussion on the status and importance of school district bullying policies.

“I don't think that the bill is quite ready to be put on the books yet,” said House Education Chair Ed McLaughlin, R-Rapid City, who cast the deciding vote. “We'll leave it to local school districts to address it.”

Nearly every committee member stressed the need to protect students through bullying policies, but less than half voted for it – a dynamic that concerned Rep. Ryan Olson, R-Onida.

“I think this committee agrees that this policy should be adopted,” Rep. Olson said, saying that if the committee voted down the bill, they'd each to have to consider what they would accept as evidence that schools have responded appropriately.

Rep. Bill Van Gerpen, R-Tyndall, voted against the legislation, but said the bill succeeded in creating awareness. It should be clear to school districts that lawmakers are interested in the issue, he said.

ASBSD opposed the legislation, walking a nuanced line against complicated state mandates while encouraging schools to develop local policy. The association has several policies relating to harassment and bullying, and ASBSD will draft a comprehensive sample policy and regulations to disseminate to schools.

The association also plans to work alongside the Department of Education and education advocacy groups to ensure school districts have resources at the local level to address the situation.

Comments (0) | Link to this story | Send to a friend | Print Story

A bill requiring all school districts to develop policies prohibiting bullying and harassment was brought back to life Wednesday.

Members of House Education brought HB 1279 off the table after the bill's sponsor, Rep. Dan Lederman, R-Dakota Dunes, said he drafted amendments to resolve opponent objections to the legislation.

The committee quickly accepted Rep. Lederman's changes, and then amended the bill a third time to refine the definition of harassment to mirror language from a Brandon Valley School District policy that prohibits bullying.

The rapid pace of action and lack of public testimony on the new measure concerned some lawmakers.

“I feel like we're running through this very rapidly, making changes on the fly that could have some unintended consequences,” said Rep. Kim Vanneman, R-Ideal. “We need to step back here and really evaluate this.”

Comments (0) | Link to this story | Send to a friend | Print Story

Lawmakers will consider whether to require school districts to adopt policies prohibiting harassment and bullying.

Rep. Dan Lederman, R-Dakota Dunes, is the prime sponsor for HB 1279, a measure that defines bullying and harassment and requires school districts to adopt anti-bullying policies by Dec. 1, 2009.

Under the bill, bullying is defined by “causing of physical hurt or psychological distress on one or more students or employees.” Harassment is defined as use of “data or computer software, written or verbal communication, or conduct” that places a student or school employee “in reasonable fear of harm” and “substantially interferes with a student's educational performance” or “substantially disrupts the orderly operation of a school.”

According to the legislation, local policies would have to:

• Define and prohibit bullying;
• Outline consequences for bullying;
• Develop mechanism for reporting bullying; and
• Develop a procedure to investigate and respond to any report of bullying.

The legislation allows local school districts the option to incorporate several other elements in to bullying and harassment policies, including a system to notify parents of any bullying incident and to determine whether any act of bullying is within the jurisdiction of the school district.

ASBSD opposes the legislation, but not the concept. The state school board association encourages school boards to adopt bullying policies, but recognizes that the scope and form of policy varies by school district and should be left to each community.

Most schools already have bullying policies. But, even if a school board has adopted a formal policy prohibiting harassment and bullying, the legislation stipulates that the board must review the policy to ensure compliance.

Comments (0) | Link to this story | Send to a friend | Print Story